Zgłoś • Board Game Arena

Wszystkie zgłoszenia

Zgłoszenia Aquatica

#161563: "I lost the chance to claim "Recruit for 5 coins" after recruiting another card for free"

fixed: Błąd został naprawiony

O czym jest to zgłoszenie?

Aquatica #643496931

Co się stało? Wybierz z poniższych opcji

Zasady: zasada gry nie była przestrzegana

Co się stało? Wybierz z poniższych opcji

Zasady: zasada gry nie była przestrzegana

Sprawdź, czy istnieje już zgłoszenie na ten sam temat

Jeśli tak, ZAGŁOSUJ na to zgłoszenie. Zgłoszenia z największą liczbą głosów mają najwyższy PRIORYTET!

#	Status	Votes	Game	Type	Title	Last update

Szczegółowy opis

Historia zgłoszeń

2025 Mar 16 13:13 • cigma • Błąd nie został jeszcze odtworzony przez programistów:

2025 Mar 16 13:14 • cigma • Błąd nie został jeszcze odtworzony przez programistów:

All this happened in the same turn.

2025 Mar 27 14:26 • MGoulet • Błąd został potwierdzony przez programistów:

Confirmed

2025 Mar 31 00:40 • FrankJones • Błąd został potwierdzony przez programistów:

So, this is confirmed as a bug. Can it be fixed? Because it just happened to me, and it might cost me the game, as I have no way to recruit another 5-coin character, and, if the game would allow me to claim it as I should be able to, I would be able to trigger the end-game and win by a good margin.

2025 Mar 31 00:49 • FrankJones • Błąd został potwierdzony przez programistów:

I didn't even acquire another character from the ocean. I haven't done anything. It's just not letting me claim the goal.

My game is:
Table #651354598
Move #152
Progression 71%

2025 Mar 31 01:43 • MGoulet • Błąd został potwierdzony przez programistów:

From game history, you cancelled your move at #152.
Actually, the bugs can be mitigate if, during the current turn, you recruit a character with 5 coins (not recruit for free a character with 5 coins cost). You have to pay at least 5 coins in mantas / location.

This bug is when you have paid your character with 5 coins and you activate a Recruit for free secondary action with a location. If this happen, you can reset your turn and complete the goal before the Recruit for free

2025 Mar 31 02:48 • FrankJones • Błąd został potwierdzony przez programistów:

I have not done a recruit for free. In fact, since buying the character for 5 coins, I have not taken any action whatsoever.

Is it in your power to revert the game to fix this is any way?

Just to make sure this is clear: On my previous turn, I paid 5 coins to recruit a character costing 5 coins, thus enabling me to be eligible for the goal.

Buit, as per the game rules, I did not wish to waste a manta yet, knowing I might need it. I wanted to wait until my next turn, use a manta, THEN claim the goal with that tired manta.

My first attempted move at move 152 was to use a location depth to recruit a character for free, but I immediately canceled it because I remembered the bug.

So, the game reverted to the original state, at which point I had literally taken zero actions since I had paid 5 coins for the ocean character.

So, the bug is NOT, in fact, triggered by using a location depth to recruit a character for free. The bug occurred because I did not claim the goal on the same turn I earned it. But we do not need to do that. The rulebook explicitly says you can achieve a goal and wait to place the manta to claim it. And all other goals follow that rule.

Can the game be reverted to game state right after I bought the character for 5 coins? My opponent's turn did not change the game state in any way. (And in fact, This would allow him to make a different move, if he wishes, and I am okay with that. I just want my 5 points for the goal so I can claim the win I obviously have.

There has to be a way to fix this. We would literally just be backing up one turn, allowing me to claim the goal I earned, and then the game can proceed as normal.

2025 Mar 31 02:51 • FrankJones • Błąd został potwierdzony przez programistów:

Also, thank you for your prompt reply to my question :)

2025 Mar 31 05:34 • FrankJones • Błąd został potwierdzony przez programistów:

Anyone can look at this game and see that I have a dominating win (against the second highest rated player) if it just lets me claim the goal I earned. Literally on this turn, I achieve the 4th goal and claim it, and then score big points on my final turn.

2025 Mar 31 05:35 • FrankJones • Błąd został potwierdzony przez programistów:

I would ask my opponent to just concede, btu I feel weird doing that.

2025 Mar 31 09:14 • FrankJones • Błąd został potwierdzony przez programistów:

I think I win anyway, but I look forward to seeing this bug fixed.

Please do not worry about trying to revert or change my existing game. I will win anyway. Thanks !

2025 Mar 31 17:26 • FrankJones • Błąd został potwierdzony przez programistów:

I was about to accumulate 5 coin resources and complete the goal a second time later in the game, and to be safe, I claimed it immediately.

2025 Apr 1 02:39 • MGoulet • Błąd został naprawiony:

@cygma : Fixed

@FrankJones : Like the goal who required 5 fully raisen location, you must complete the goal during the turn you recruit with at least 5 coins.

2025 Apr 1 06:47 • FrankJones • Błąd został naprawiony:

Noted, thank you. That makes sense.

Is that also true for two other similar goals that could be difficult to verify if not claimed on the turn when it happens?

Those are:

1) "Discard all but one of your character cards"
2) "Have 10 or more character cards in your discard pile"

I would assume those must be claimed with a manta while the condition is true, and cannot be claimed once the condition becomes false. So, playing the Matrona, for example, and then going to the next turn without claiming the goal for those two goals, would cause a similar situation to not claiming the "recruit a character for 5 coins" goal?

Dodaj coś do tego zgłoszenia

Dodaj tutaj wszystko, co wydaje się istotne dla odtworzenia tego błędu lub zrozumienia twojej propozycji:

Kolejne ID stołu / ID ruchu
Czy F5 rozwiązało problem?
Czy problem zdarzył się kilka razy? Za każdym razem? Losowo?
Jeżeli masz zrzut ekranu z tym błędem (dobry zwyczaj) możesz użyć Imgur.com, żeby wrzucić go do Internetu i potem skopiować łącze do niego tutaj.

Anuluj Uaktualnij zgłoszenie

#161563: "I lost the chance to claim "Recruit for 5 coins" after recruiting another card for free"

O czym jest to zgłoszenie?

Co się stało? Wybierz z poniższych opcji

Co się stało? Wybierz z poniższych opcji

Sprawdź, czy istnieje już zgłoszenie na ten sam temat

Szczegółowy opis

Historia zgłoszeń

Dodaj coś do tego zgłoszenia

Zmień status zgłoszenia na:

Pomoc

Wkład

Nawiguj

Śledź nas na